AI Plugin Indexwriter-reader vs discussion
writer-reader and discussion are both search and web skills. discussion scores higher (84 vs 70 out of 100). discussion has more GitHub stars (5.9k), and writer-reader was updated more recently (4 days ago). The table compares them side by side.
| writer-reader | discussion | |
|---|---|---|
| Score | 70 / 100 | 84 / 100 |
| What it does | Simulate a specified first-time reader's reactions to fiction, tracking curiosity, tension, attachment, confusion, and payoff without presenting simulation as real audience research. | Runs structured multi-agent discussions for open-ended typia topics. Use only when the user explicitly asks for Discussion or a team debate with transcripts and conclusions; do not use for Self-Review, a solo or multi-agent review, research review, or issue discovery. |
| Publisher | Community: Firstp1ck | Community: samchon |
| Grades | Maintenance A, Licence A, Quality B | Maintenance A, Licence A, Quality A |
| npm downloads a week | Not on npm | Not on npm |
| Runs | Skill | Skill |
| Works with | Claude Code, Claude apps | Claude Code, Claude apps |
| GitHub stars | 91 | 5,944 |
| Last commit | 17 Oct 2026 | 15 Oct 2026 |
| Licence | MIT | MIT |
| Listed since | 20 Oct 2026 | 20 Oct 2026 |
| Install writer-reader | Install discussion |
Questions
Is writer-reader or discussion more popular?
discussion has more GitHub stars: 5,944.
Can I use writer-reader and discussion together?
Yes. AI assistants can load several skills at once. Install both and the assistant picks the right one for each task.